Very nice discussion is going on this thread.
At first after reading the post, I also got confused by striking similarities between two patterns thought one is design pattern other one is application pattern.
Survic has written a nice post on confusion regarding MVC.
This is one of best articulated posts that I have come across on this topic.
If you don’t understand confusion about MVC then read
First there are two documented versions of MVC
Here is sample of discussion on MVC and ASP.Net in which I took part
If you thought that this is enough then there is a MVP pattern.
After that Martin Fowler splits MVP into two parts to clear confusion (But now I am more confused)
I always use MVC as GUI or WEB based design pattern.
MVC is a design pattern for Interactive Interfaces.(LudovicoVan corrected me)
MVC in web context is more geared towards streaming HTML to different devices that understand HTML while 3 layer architecture is independent of any technology.
One comment was that we should implement MVC in every layer of application.
I think that I know what the poster is implying.
Generally I believe in understanding the intent of pattern and implementing it my way that suits my project. But at the same time, we have to maintain some essence of design pattern for clear communication. While I understand what the poster is implying, I think that are specific patterns (factory,fascade,process layer,Aggregation etc) to describe the patterns applicable to good enterprise distributed computing needs.
Note: I am going to revisit this post
I was recently debugging Web Site functionality issue with a client. We were not able to reproduce the issues at our end. I saw that the c...
Survic has very nicely argued that database storage and retrieval is 80% ( I would say 70%) portion of application. Mocks ups, Screen Desig...
Petshop Architecture 4.0 I have used earlier Petshop Architecture. It left a mixed feeling. It was simple to start with but not extensible...
Architecture - client requires at least rudimentary skills in these areas. What is SOA? Benefits? SOA principles for WS? Name standard arc...